The Benjamin Yount Show 9-3-26 7am
Lots of schools across Wisconsin are asking for more money.
Voters will decide on hundreds of millions of dollars worth of school referendum questions in November. Each school district is asking for something different. Some schools want money to pay for salaries and benefits. Others want money for new buildings, or building upgrades.
My kids’ school, ElmBrook Schools, is asking for $100 million. The district says it HAS to make upgrades at four schools. Some of those upgrades are for ADA issues. The district also says it needs to do some general upkeep, fix at least one parking lot, and "Update robotics, woods, art and technology classrooms to meet curriculum standards."
There are already Yes signs in front yards.
I was talking with a neighbor the other day, and he asked about the signs. I explained that the school district, where his kids go as well, wants $100 million dollars. He was flabbergasted.
This guy is much more liberal than I am. His wife just got a job in the school district. He’s the kind of guy who supports his local schools. But it was the business question that got me. “$100, what’s the return on investment on that?”
ElmBrook Schools are, ostensibly, the best school district in the state. Nearly 30% of students get the highest score on reading tests, and nearly 40% get the highest scores on math tests. In a state where, on average, a third of kids can read at grade-level, essentially a third of ElmBrook kids are reading far above grade level.
The schools are nice, safe, and clean. The football field is new and beautiful. I like that there are robots, woods, art, and technology classrooms in almost every school. I moved to Brookfield because of the schools. I would recommend ElmBrook Schools to anyone.
But I don’t have an answer for my neighbor’s simple question: What is the return on investment for $100 million.
My neighbor said, in his business, they’ll invest $100 million into a new factory. But they expect to see a profit, or expanded production, or a new line to follow. They are “investing” rather than simply spending.
ElmBrook Schools have not made the case that improving the traffic flow at Pilgrim Park is going to return on our investment. Same thing with the cafeteria upgrades at Wisconsin Hills.
The ADA stuff? That sounds important. But why hasn’t that been done already? And I’ve been to these schools, they have ramps and elevators already.
Then there are the other questions, like the brand new district office the ElmBrook built a few years ago, the six-figure Chief Strategy Officer, on the $10 million that the school district has spent on ball field, pools, and locker room updates over the past decade.
ElmBrooke Schools are excellent schools. Excellent. They routinely turn out smart, well rounded, great kids. That is certain. But parents should ask whether their kids will be $100 million better. Can their kids get $100 million better? And will new traffic flow, new ramps, new paint, a new gym, and maybe some new classrooms make them $100 million better? Or is this a case of a school district with a lot of bills to pay and a lengthy wish list, who knows its parents won’t blink at a $66 per-year extra property tax increase because it’s “what’s best for the kids.”
We will find out. And I’ll let you know if I ever get an answer about the return on that $100 million investment.
photo credit: Getty Images